APPENDIX
A: Jampa Mandalas
Due
to the scarcity of historical records, it is extremely difficult
to identify the Jampa mandalas, or to base identifications with
utter certainty on the inscriptions in the gompa. Both Keith Dowman
and Roberto Vitali (see Bibliography)
have offered a set of identifications for the twenty mandalas of
the lower register of the main floor. Both note that they base their
identifications on the inscriptions below the mandalas, mentioning
no other source for these identifications. Lama Jorden considers,
however, that relying on these inscriptions for positive identification
with complete certainty is problematic, for several reasons:
-
The inscriptions themselves are not complete;
-
In certain instances, a single verse inscription includes two
or three names of deities: e.g., lines 105-108 of an inscription
verse (See Appendix B: Inscriptions)
carry the names of Amitabha and Avalokiteshvara. Thus, for the
mandala on north wall # 6, Dowman identifies Avalokiteshvara,
while Vitali gives Amitabha.
While
it is true that these two deities are connected within their "tathagatha
family," wherein Avalokiteshvara is the Bodhisattva form of
Dhyani-Buddha Amitabha, and thus making allowance for the multiple
aspects of certain deities, these two identifications are not entirely
congruent. Moreover, even if the inscriptions relate to identification
of the mandalas, no scholar at present has the expertise to reach
final conclusions on certain names found in these inscriptions.
Interpretation of these inscriptions and their intended purpose
is complex and uncertain, and we need to be very careful in attributing
names to the mandalas. Further research and study by a Sakya-pa
lama who has expertise on these mandalas and on rituals that are
closely related to them, along with review of the inscriptions,
is warranted.
Dowman's
and Vitali's identifications are given here, keyed to our wall layouts.
A list of 54 mandalas found in Mustang appears in "Lo (Mustang)
ko Sanskritik Sampada" (Nepali text), by Prayag Raj Sharma
and Jagman Gurung (see Bibliography). Some of the identifications
offered by Dowman and by Vitali can be matched to particular mandalas
listed in Sharma and Gurung. In addition, some partial identifications
have been offered or suggested by the Khenpo Rinpoche of Lo Monthang
and members of the Lo community. As noted above, further research
may help to confirm or add to these identifications.
We have added a few translations or explanatory note, in brackets,
of the names of lesser-known deities and supramundane beings. The
list below is based on Dowman's identifications, which he gives
in Sanskrit, while Vitali's are in transliterated Tibetan. Where
there is any slight variance, we have noted Vitali's identification.
East
wall, south section:
- Vajrasattva
with Ashtamahanaga retinue [Eight Naga and Nagini couples].
-
Jvalanala
[the name Jvalanala signifies blazing flame, identified as a wrathful
form of Vairocana] with Ashtagraha and Naksatra retinue [Eight
planets and nine constellations].
- Vajrasattva
with Dasadikpala retinue [10 Directional Guardians].
South
wall:
-
Vajrapani
(as Vajrasattva) with Chaturmaharaja retinue [Four Guardian
Kings].
-
Karmakula
of Amoghasiddhi [kula signifies family; here, the action or
activity family headed by this Dhyani-Buddha].
-
Karmakula
of Avalokiteshvara.
-
Karmakula
of Trailokya-vijaya. {Vitali gives Mi 'gyur rdo rje, a form
of Trailokya-vijaya that can be understood as belonging to the
action family or mind aspect of Vajrasattva: i.e., his
unchangeable--hence Vajra--mind. See inscription verses 109-111.}
-
Karmakula
of Vairocana.
-
Tsargyu
tsawa'i Nam-nying? (probably Akashagarbha-mulatantra mandala).
West
wall, south section:
-
Vajradhatu
[Diamond sphere].
West
wall, north section:
-
Dharmadhatu
Vajisvara [a form of Manjushri].
North
wall:
-
Manjughosa
[a form of Manjushri].
-
illegible
-
illegible
-
illegible
-
illegible
- Avalokiteshvara.
{Vitali gives 'od dpag med, the Tibetan name for Amitabha. See
inscription verses 105-108.}
East
Wall, north section:
-
Trailokya-vijaya
as Akshobhyavajra. {Vitali gives Mi bskyod rdo rje, the Tibetan
name for Akshobhya.}
-
Mahakrodha
Jvalanala with Ashtamahadeva retinue [Eight Great Gods].
-
Chakravartin?
[Universal monarch] {or} Trailokya-vijaya with Navabhairava retinue
[Nine Bhairavas--terrifying deities, one of whom appears below
the throne of the deity; the Bhairavas are seen here in consort
with their shaktis].
|